Bridges
Good Old Days or Deceptive Haze: How Does Nostalgia Shape Us and Our Society?
March 9, 2025
Discussion Questions
These questions are just to start and aid discussion. Please skip around in the list, indulge diversions, and let your discussion develop naturally.
-
What does the word "nostalgia" bring to your mind? Do your own thoughts on the concept differ from the formal Oxford definition: "a sentimental longing or wistful affection for the past, typically for a period or place with happy personal associations."?
-
Are you nostalgic? What triggers your nostalgia? Do you do anything to indulge your nostalgia? (looking at old pictures, movies, books, talking to friends with similar memories, collecting things, etc).
-
What is the difference between nostalgia-influenced memory and objective memory?
-
Some people express nostalgia only within the frame of their own experiences and memories; Others engage nostalgia for an era they never experienced ("historical nostalgia" in the video below). How is interest in an era before-your-time different than memory-driven nostalgia? How is it the same? Can nostalgia fuel experiences now that you couldn't access in the past (due to financial constraints or other barriers)? How much is nostalgia just a marketing ploy similar to fashion trends and other consumer manipulations?
-
On balance, is nostalgia more harmful or helpful to societal progress? We're all familiar with the destructive nostalgia used in the American MAGA movement to point to a (mostly delusional) "good old days" - are there counters to this that use nostalgia to build a better community or polity?
-
What age were you when you first felt nostalgic? If you haven't yet felt it, when, if ever, do you think you will? For older folks, did the video below's discussion of nostalgia in the youngest current adult generation (Z) surprise you? Is nostalgia in youth different than nostalgia in old age?
-
What can we do in the present to personally or collectively create experiences and social structures worthy of (non-delusional) nostalgia in the future?